The AI Safety Menu

All laws

Every law and bill on The AI Safety Menu, with what it costs America's lead over China over 3 years and how much it changes p(doom), the chance of an AI catastrophe. Rough starting points; play the menu to change them.

Safety laws

LawLead costp(doom)
Rulebook with a floorunder a day−0.12 points
Background checksunder a day−0.12 points
DNA order screeningnone−0.92 points
Humans control nukesnone−0.36 points
Incident reportsnone−0.25 points
Transparency reportunder a day−0.12 points
Yearly auditunder a day−0.25 points
Outside safety testsunder a day−0.86 points
Safety testsunder a day−0.66 points
Safety planunder a day−0.25 points
4-week test periodunder a day−0.66 points
U.S.–China safety dealunder a day−0.57 points
Limits on AI surveillanceunder a day−0.12 points
Whistleblower protectionunder a day−0.48 points
Red team if riskyunder a day−0.66 points
Fund defensive techunder a day−0.71 points
Kill switch1 day−0.48 points
No open-weight frontier models2 days−0.48 points
Power-grab safeguards2 days−0.48 points
Safety review before release2 days−1.2 points
Chips that enforce rules3 days−0.84 points
Checks before lab use4 days−1.1 points
Clearances for lab staff5 days−0.48 points
Liability insurance5 days−0.33 points
Alignment moonshot6 days−1.3 points
International AI agency6 days−2 points
Liability for AI harms9 days−0.33 points
30-day training notice9 days−0.25 points
No capabilities papers9 days−0.07 points
Air-gapped labs9 days−0.71 points
Pause with China11 days−2 points
Limit AI-run research12 days−1.1 points
Limit AI agents3 weeks−0.92 points
U.S. 6-month pause7 weeks−0.2 points
License to train2.5 months−1.5 points
A third of R&D on safety3.5 months−1.6 points
Global superintelligence ban3.5 months−4.4 points
Global pause5 months−4.1 points
Global compute cap8 months−3.1 points
U.S. compute cap13 months−0.4 points
U.S. superintelligence ban17 months−0.6 points

Safety laws that also gain lead

LawLead costp(doom)
Cloud ID checksgains 5 days−0.25 points
Guard models from theftgains 1 day−0.71 points

Other AI laws

LawLead costp(doom)
Ban deepfake pornunder a daynone
Label AI in political adsunder a daynone
AI layoff noticeunder a daynone
Anti-bias rulesunder a daynone
Watermark AI contentunder a daynone
Chatbot safety rulesunder a daynone
Block Big Tech AI deals9 daysnone
AI dividend9 daysnone
Pay for training data3 monthsnone

Race to win

LawLead costp(doom)
Threaten to sabotage China's AIgains 4.5 months+0.1 points
Chip export bangains 2.5 monthsnone
Government compute buildoutgains 2 months+0.15 points
AI Manhattan Projectgains 5 weeks+0.2 points
Fast permits for data centersgains 4 weeksnone
Track exported chipsgains 2 weeksnone
Fund U.S. open modelsgains 9 days+0.15 points
Shield AI firms from lawsuitsgains 7 days+0.36 points
Fast-track visasgains 6 daysnone
Rush AI into combatgains 4 days+0.15 points
Build chips at homegains 3 daysnone
Public research computeunder a daynone
Killer robots, no limitsunder a day+0.15 points
Cut government AI testingunder a day+0.05 points
Ban state AI lawsunder a day+2.6 points
Stop model copyingunder a day−0.12 points
$100K H-1B fee6 daysnone
Sell chips to China6 weeksnone

Real bills

LawLead costp(doom)
SB 1047gains 2 days−1.2 points
EU AI Actgains 1 day−2 points
New York RAISEunder a day−0.43 points
Warner NSA billunder a day−0.66 points
Hawley–Blumenthalunder a day−1.2 points
California SB 53under a day−0.57 points
FRONTIER Act3 days−0.5 points
2023 pause letter7 weeks−0.2 points